Thursday, August 30, 2007

Publishers Fighting Public Access to Publicly Funded Research

A recent announcement from ARL regarding the PRISM coalition of publishers working to prevent public access policies ( "There's lots of commentary out there and as usual Peter Suber is staying right on top of it ( I want to take the opportunity to point out an issue brief that ARL created last winter when the news of publishers' plans for a smear campaign broke. You can find it at " A copy is also available from the Library website for faster access.

Information on the NIH proposal is available from our Scholarly Communication web pages. We'd like to hear your thoughts on the campaign by publishers to prevent public access policies.

Links to related articles

9/11/2007 "Project of Publishers' Association Is Criticized by Some of Its Members and Open-Access Advocates" - update in Chronicle of Higher Education, Sept. 11

"University-Press Leader Quit Publishers' Panel Over Anti-Open-Access Campaign", Chronicle of Higher Ed, Sept. 11, 2007

"Critics Say Publishers' PRISM Initiative Causing More Discord than Discussion "

1 comment:

  1. Meanwhile, in Canada, a recent development on their public access. From a press release:

    "Open access to health research publications: CIHR unveils new policy

    For immediate release-


    Ottawa (September 4, 2007) - Today, the Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR) unveiled a new policy to promote public access to the results of research it has funded. CIHR will require its researchers to ensure that their original research articles are freely available online within six months of publication.

    "Timely and unrestricted access to research findings is a defining feature of science, and is essential for advancing knowledge and accelerating our understanding of human health and disease," stated Dr. Alan Bernstein, President of the Canadian Institutes of Health Research. "With the development of the internet it is now feasible to disseminate globally and easily the results of research that we fund. As a publicly-funded organization, we have a responsibility to ensure that new advances in health research are available to those who need it and can use it - researchers world-wide, the public and policy makers."

    In developing its policy, CIHR struck a broadly representative national task force of leading researchers, chaired by Dr. James Till of the Princess Margaret Hospital. CIHR consulted widely with Canadian researchers and stakeholders in government, research, publishing and the library communities. CIHR also looked to the experiences of funding agencies in other countries who have established similar policies. The consultation process was thorough and carefully planned in order to preserve academic freedom while promoting the value of public access.

    "This open access policy will serve as a model for other funding agencies," said Dr. James E. Till of the Princess Margaret Hospital in Toronto. "The policy will leverage taxpayers' investment by accelerating research and by fostering its broader application."

    Under this new Policy, which will apply to all grants awarded after January 1, 2008 that receive funding in whole or in part from CIHR, grant recipients must make every effort to ensure that their peer-reviewed research articles are freely available as soon as possible after publication. This can be achieved by depositing the article in an archive, such as PubMed Central or an institutional repository, and/or by publishing results in an open access journal. A growing number of journals already meet these requirements and CIHR-funded researchers are encouraged to consider publishing in these journals.

    Additionally, grant recipients are now required to deposit bioinformatics, atomic, and molecular coordinate data, as already required by most journals, into the appropriate public database immediately upon publication of research results.

    This policy builds on other important initiatives to promote openness and transparency of CIHR-funded research such as the registration of clinical trials and randomized controlled trials.

    The policy on Access to CIHR-funded Research Outputs is available online."